Game Disputes

[johnNYCage]

red happily killed a CC that was burning from illegal (accidental or not but still illegal) activity from a teammate.  and teal happily went mid at the same time.

[korean]to[]

red is a fucking idiot, confirmed by everyone, but teal im pretty sure went mid BEFORE or during same time i was hunting scvs. not sure on this tho

[CoR[BF]]

L
O
L
another season of guiding light!

[Tr0uble]

Pr1me dodge: Stands as reported.

Kyu DQ: "If a player's "idle unit(s)" bomb(s) supply depots, pylons, or tech, pause the game and inform the other team. The accused player or someone on their team must kill the equivalent units/structures in their own base to even it out.  For example:  If a player accidentally leaves 6 idle wraiths in an enemies base resulting in the razing of 4 supply depots, the affected team must pause the game and inform the other team of what happened.  If there is any dispute with this, complete the game, save it, and then report it to a League Admin."

Kyu got a dodge earlier this season when this same exact thing happened to him. He left the game w/o finishing it. Brat never queued scv's or didn't complete the game. Report is dodge on Brat.

[Pr1meIVI]

The thing was I attempted to join back into bnet and even gave notification my Internet all of a sudden shut down, I had no reason to dodge.

[Pr1meIVI]

Jc is right I even have notification within 5 minutes of my absence when I disconnected according to rules, please over rule.

Thank you

[Tr0uble]

It's happened to others, sorry. It's a 100% dick bag move to report it as dodge b/c you know the person isn't TRULY dodging, but still technically right. Rule needs to be changed imo...if other people hadn't gotten a dodge before for the same exact thing, I would say no dodge.

[Pr1meIVI]

kk myst can you please post bot log of when everyone joined channel after the game got disconnected and compare the difference from my time of notification on the website.

Pr1meIVI: Fuuuuuuck
Today at 01:09:12 AM
Pr1meIVI: Internet disconnected for some reason
Today at 01:08:47 AM
Pr1meIVI: Can't log in right now
Today at 01:08:32 AM

If the player that disconnects doesn't return within 5 minutes of remaking the game or doesn't notify any of the players of its absence, it is a dodge.

[Ah-Lee]

I post dodge after 5 mins tho....

[Tr0uble]

Brat, JC, looose, and Kyu have all gotten dodges for same thing. I don't agree with it, but still within the rules. Rule should have something like "if a player notifies the others that he/she cannot log on within 5min, a dodge CANNOT be given to the disconnected player"

And then something else about the game being done again in 15min, but then people will cry that they shouldn't have to wait 15min to remake a game. Catch 22 with this shit...

[Ah-Lee]

Idk can't argue

[Pr1meIVI]

understand, but GIVEN I did notify of my absence within 5 minutes, the dodge should be revoked.

regardles my points are
- there was no save of the game.
- not in a position of losing
- not intentional
- notified within 5 minutes since dodge would only result IF person didnt notify anyone.

from bot log
[01:05:30 AM] [BNCS] 10053 -- Connection is aborted due to timeout or other failure
[01:05:30 AM] [BNCS] Disconnected.
[01:05:30 AM] [BNCS] The Battle.net server has terminated your connection.
[01:05:30 AM] [BNCS] Attempting to reconnect in 1 second...
[01:05:31 AM] Connecting your bot...
[01:05:31 AM] [BNLS] Connecting to the BNLS server at bnls.mattkv.net...
[01:05:46 AM] [BNLS] Connection to bnls.mattkv.net failed.
[01:05:46 AM] [BNLS] Locating other BNLS servers...
[01:05:53 AM] [BNLS] An error occured while trying to locate an alternative BNLS server.
[01:05:53 AM] [BNLS]   You may not be connected to the internet or may be having DNS resolution issues.
[01:05:53 AM] [BNLS]   Visit http://www.stealthbot.net/ and check the Technical Support forum for more info

so given another 1-2 minutes from this, I did post on site asap.

[Tr0uble]

And if other people hadn't received a dodge for this stuff, then you wouldn't either. Like I said, I don't agree with it, but the standard has been a dodge in the past for everyone else.

[Pr1meIVI]

Lol maybe if they read rules more thoroughly, they could see legitimate reasons of dodges being avoided.

[killer]

- If the player that disconnects doesn't return within 5 minutes of remaking the game or doesn't notify any of the players of its absence, it is a dodge.

Pr1meIVI: Fuuuuuuck
Today at 01:09:12 AM
Pr1meIVI: Internet disconnected for some reason
Today at 01:08:47 AM
Pr1meIVI: Can't log in right now

idk whats with you people that you cant read but the rules clearly state all of these disputes yet go on for days. he dropped. couldnt sign back on. notified the game. why would he get a dodge cuz he cant sign back on? clearly isnt his fault. the guy didnt dodge. not to mention half you people pull plug when getting massacred to rm ums so if his team wasnt losing why would he get dodge but not when people pull plug when their mains gone they are broke and other team goes mid? ridiculous